Unread Friends guide

How to host a murder mystery party without a kit

By Joel Rightler · 2026-11-18

You can host a murder mystery party without a kit by writing a small case yourself: one victim, four or five suspects, a timeline and a stack of clues that each point somewhere. Split the clues between your guests so they have to talk, collect a private guess from everyone, then reveal the answer. If you would rather play than write, a co-op mystery app can deal the case for you.

Choose the format and who knows the answer

There are two ways to run a home-made murder mystery. In a roleplay party, each guest plays a suspect, reads a short character sheet and hides a secret, and one of them is the killer. In an investigation party, everyone is on the same side and solves the case from evidence. Roleplay needs a sheet for every guest and works best with six to twelve people who enjoy performing. An investigation needs one clue pack and suits friends who would rather argue about a timeline than put on an accent.

Whoever writes the case knows the answer, so that person hosts. They read the opening, hand out clues, keep time and run the reveal. If you want to play as well, swap with a friend: each of you writes a case for the other's party.

Write the case in one evening

Start with the answer and work backwards. Write down who did it, how, and why before anything else.

Set it somewhere your friends already understand: a birthday dinner, a book club, an office party, a weekend in a rented cabin. A familiar setting means less explaining at the start.

Give each of four or five suspects a motive, a chance to do it and a reason to lie. Only the killer's story holds up on all three. Every other suspect has one hole that a careful reader can find, and finding those holes is how the group narrows it down.

Write a timeline of the night in fifteen minute steps, showing where each suspect says they were. The killer's version has one gap that a clue can expose.

Then write twelve to twenty clues. Each one should rule a suspect out or point toward the killer. Keep red herrings to two or three, because more than that makes the middle of the night drag. Before the party, give the pack to someone who is not coming and check they can solve it in under an hour.

Make clues from things you already have

A clue only has to look like something a person would leave behind. Print a text thread typed out with names and times. Write a note by hand and crumple it. Use a real receipt with the time circled, a train ticket, a photo with something important in the background, or a typed transcript of a voicemail.

Put the clues in numbered envelopes and give each guest their own envelope of three or four. Nobody sees everything, so the case only gets solved when people read their clues out and compare. This also gives the quietest guest something the group needs, and the others have to ask them about it.

Release clues in rounds: the first envelopes on arrival, a second set after food, and one final clue before the vote. Rounds give the night a shape and stop the group from solving it in the first twenty minutes.

Want a mystery your group solves together tonight?

The Blue Dish, the first case, is playable by anyone. Friends who join never pay.

Run the night, the vote and the reveal

Open with a five minute read from the host: who died, where, when, and who was there. Then run rounds of about twenty minutes, with food in between.

When the last clue is out, everyone writes their answer on a slip of paper in private: who did it, how, and why. Fold the slips and collect them. A private vote stops the loudest guess from becoming everyone's guess.

For the reveal, the host reads the solution and walks through the two or three clues that decided it, then opens the slips. If your group likes a winner, give a point for each part a guest got right. Allow about ninety minutes for a home-made case, including food.

Where Unread Friends fits

If you would rather solve than write, Unread Friends deals the case for you. Each friend gets a different set of phones from the night of the case: texts, call logs, photos and notes. It works like the numbered envelopes, without the printing, and the host does not know the answer either, so everyone plays.

One friend hosts and opens a room. Everyone else joins with the room code, by scanning the QR code on the host's lobby screen, or from a web browser at playunread.app/join. It runs on iPhone, iPad and Android, and an Apple TV can show the shared pin board for the whole room. When the group is ready, the host opens the vote, everyone answers in private, and the reveal shows the truth and how each friend voted.

It does not include costumes or character scripts. If your group wants to dress up and play suspects, a home-made roleplay party is the better night, and you can still borrow the private vote.

Which case to start with

The Blue Dish is playable by anyone, takes 2 to 4 players and runs about ten minutes. Play it first to check that every phone connects.

Big Night Packs 1 to 6 take 3 to 10 players, and each case runs 60 to 65 minutes. Big Night Packs 7 and 8 take 2 to 6 players and run 45 to 60 minutes. Pack 7 ends with a death at a riad in Marrakech, for groups who want a murder to solve.

A pack of three cases is $9.99 and a single case is $4.99 (US prices). The host pays once and can host that case again. Friends who join never pay.

Try Unread Friends with your group.

The Blue Dish, the first case, is playable by anyone. Friends who join never pay.

← About Unread Friends